Eurodad logo
Eurodad logo

Untying the knots - How the World Bank is failing to deliver real change on conditionality

09 November 2007

In 2005 the World Bank launched a review of its conditionality policy. This was in response to growing international criticism, from developed and developing countries alike, that the World Bank was still attaching too many intrusive and, at times, harmful economic policy conditions to its development finance to poor countries. 

Two years on from this important step, the World Bank is keen to represent the problem of conditionality as one that has been dealt with, and that is no longer a major problem in lending.  In order to independently assess whether or not this is the case, this report, by the European Network on Debt and Development (Eurodad), assesses the effectiveness of the World Bank’s Good Practice Principles (GPPs) in reforming World Bank conditionality.

The report finds that the GPPs have, as hoped, had a positive impact in reducing the overall number of conditions that the World Bank attaches to its development finance in poor countries. However, unfortunately there has been very limited progress in curbing the Bank’s practice of attaching sensitive economic policy conditions like privatisation and liberalisation conditions to its lending.

The Bank may be slimming down the number of conditions it uses in developing countries, but it is still making heavy use of economic policy conditionality, especially in sensitive areas such as privatisation and liberalisation. 

In short, this report highlights serious concerns with the Bank’s implementation of the Good Practice Principles.

Eurodad, along with NGOs across Europe, believe that the World Bank should end its use of economic policy conditionality, which too often promotes sensitive and externally induced policy choices. Instead, grants and loans should be accompanied by a set of responsible financing standardswhich are mutually agreed by the Bank and recipient countries.

Informes.

Últimos informes

16 April 2010:  - Financial architecture - Capital Flight - Governance - International Financial Institutions
El coste de las reservas: Los países en desarrollo están pagando el precio de la inestabilidad financiera mundial

28 March 2008:  - Aid effectiveness
Cambiando las tornas: ayuda y responsabilidad en el marco de París

05 March 2008:  - Financial architecture - Debt sustainability - Illegitimate debt
Carta de financiación responsable Eurodad

22 November 2007:  - Bilateral debt
Canjes de deuda por desarrollo. Respuesta creativa o cortina de humo?

16 November 2007:  - Bilateral debt
Canjes de deuda por desarrollo, respuesta creativa o cortina de humo?

09 November 2007:  - Aid effectiveness
Enlazando el análisis presupuestario con la incidencia política en la ayuda al desarrollo

08 June 2007:  - Debt overview
Romper la cadena. La deuda pública de Bolivia

20 April 2007:  - Illegitimate debt
¿Por qué asumió Noruega su responsabilidad como país acreedor? – La Campaña de la Exportación Naviera

15 May 2006:  - Debt sustainability
Revisión del BM y FMI del Marco de Sostenibilidad de la Deuda

30 January 2006:  - Multilateral debt
Justicia para América latina a propósito de la deuda con el BID

20 November 2005:  - Poverty analysis and strategies
Conferencia electrónica de EURODAD sobre los análisis de los impactos sociales

15 September 2005:  - Financial architecture - Poverty analysis and strategies
Los estudios de impacto en líena de mira

14 September 2005:  - Poverty analysis and strategies
La experiencia con los analisis de impacto social y de probreza (PSIA) en Nicaragua

14 September 2005:  - Debt sustainability
Una Respuesta no Adecuada: El nuevo marco de sostenibilidad de la deuda del Banco Mundial/FMI